If you’re trying to decide what’s better, Ipsy or Birchbox, consider which types of products you would rather receive. But which beauty box is the right choice for you? There are often discounts or promotions that allow you to snag these products for less than you would find at the store, and they also offer free gifts with purchase that make it worth your while to shop the Birchbox site instead of, say, Sephora. Ipsy … AdvisoryHQ (All Rights Reserved). Birchbox vs. Ipsy: Which is the Better Makeup Subscription Box? Ipsy vs. Birchbox: What’s the Basic Difference? Birchbox features a lot of products they usually include in the box on their official website, whereas Ipsy is more like a surprise and send products based on your quiz. Includes some drugstore products, which don’t feel like an exciting new discovery. Farm Foods Market Review: Do I Recommend? The Birchbox for men subscription comes with a slightly higher price tag than the basic Birchbox or Ipsy subscription, but it does offer a completely unique service. I wouldn’t say I hate Birchbox… Under brand offers, you’re taken to a page with discount codes from the brands offered in that month’s Ipsy Bag. If you’re trying to decide Ipsy vs. Birchbox, the degree of customization won’t be the deciding factor; both services offer similar ways to personalize the products you receive. Original review: May 22, 2020. ​In the past, subscribers used to have the ability to earn points by leaving reviews for products. Ipsy is great for those on a make up budget. The selection is pretty small, especially compared to Birchbox, which makes it harder to find full-size versions of the samples you like. With the purchase of an annual subscription to either Ipsy or Birchbox, you will receive one month for free. The answer will tell you which is better, Birchbox or Ipsy, for you personally. Ipsy’s makeup tends to be pretty high-quality, even with the inclusion of drugstore items from time to time. Rather, they go towards additional items to be included in your next Glam Bag. Moink vs Butcher Box [2021 Comparison] – Which One Should You Choose? Usually one or more full-size items per box, Chooses all samples for you, but has a more detailed questionnaire, Offers discounts and promotions on popular brands, Offers generous discounts to be used on brands’ websites. They also include makeup tools from time to time, such as brushes or sponges. In a different vein, a men’s beauty box subscription is also almost unheard of, but not in the Ipsy vs. Birchbox debate. Each month’s delivery comes wrapped in a unique makeup bag, whereas the Birchbox subscription will … Review AdvisoryHQ’s, Note: Firms and products, including the one(s) reviewed above, may be AdvisoryHQ's affiliates. Below is a breakdown of how the two boxes compare: Bottom Line: Overall, I love Birchbox for the skin care products and hair products they offer. Ipsy tends to send more make up while occasionally doing a skin are bag. I was told by someone who commented on my blog awhile ago that I should try Ipsy… Subscriptions to beauty boxes like Birchbox, Ipsy and Sephora Play – which are filled with samples of makeup, perfumes, creams and more – are booming. ButcherBox vs Omaha Steaks [2021]: Which is Better? Between Birchbox vs. Ipsy, the convenience of cutting out the middle step would land Ipsy as the clear winner for easy personalization. Ipsy provides shoppers with the chance to get personalized recommendations based on their coloring, makeup behaviors, and more. Birchbox costs $15 per month, whereas Ipsy costs $12 per month. Be sure to check this page for the latest deals and promos. Check out our beauty box comparison chart below, then keep reading to see detailed reviews … Both also offer some sort of shop option on the site itself where you can purchase full-sized versions of the products included in the box, among others. Here’s the scoop: Companies like Birchbox or Ipsy are known for bringing a degree of personalization to online health and beauty shopping. It is still difficult to find a perfect match for products based off this collection of information, but it does help their stylists to figure out which products might be more interesting to you. For consumers who aren’t sure if they want to pay the sometimes exorbitant price tag attached to high-end beauty, wellness, or lifestyle products, these sampler boxes can help them decide. So, which is better, Birchbox or Ipsy? Click to view AdvisoryHQ's, ► Get Featured on AdvisoryHQ. The main differences between Birchbox vs Ipsy are: Bottom Line up Front: Overall, I prefer the Birchbox subscription for the skin care and hair care (beauty products) they offer. Because Birchbox specializes in pricier products, their store discount might give you a little bit of flexibility on whether that new product can fit into your budget. However, unlike Birchbox, you cannot use these points to shop in their online store. Birchbox offers shipping only in the USA, whereas Ipsy also sends cosmetics to Canada too. There are more ways for you to gain points, such as by following Ipsy on social media, reviewing their products, referring friends and family, and writing a review of the Glam Bag as a whole. Comparing Birchbox vs. Ipsy, you’ll see that the packaging from Ipsy has a greater degree of versatility. At first glance, the services offered by Ipsy or Birchbox appear to be very similar, but there are definitely differences between the two companies. When it comes to reviews, what’s better: Ipsy or Birchbox? 18 Best Organic Meat Delivery Services [2021]. Points cannot be put towards items in their online shop. So, last month I re-subscribed to Ipsy after a 6 month hiatus. Comparison and review of the April 2015 Ipsy vs Birchbox subscriptions. There are hundreds of brands featured on their site and in their boxes, both high- and low-end, to offer customers a variety of products and allow subscribers to try new things (although Birchbox does tend towards higher-end products—you won’t find any drugstore brands in this box). Birchbox has been around since September 2010. After a week of no bag I checked it, and it was not a good tracking number. They deliver to USA and Canada drop to PO boxes, FPO boxes, APO, and DPO. How can you determine which beauty subscription box to choose from between Ipsy vs. Birchbox? Each giveaway has a retail value over $100. I originally cancelled Ipsy … In November of 2016, after taking into account the decreased price for sample sizes, she found that the November Birchbox was worth approximately $42.30 to Ipsy’s $46. To treat myself to the new year, I decided to invest in getting a makeup subscription … They envisioned a way that customers could test new products and then easily buy them if they liked them. Under Ipsy offers, there are a handful of full-size products you can purchase from the Ipsy website itself. There’s no way to recycle them, which feels like a waste. As you can see, there isn’t much of a difference between the Ipsy vs. Birchbox value. In contrast, Ipsy allows your points to go towards bonus items available in future boxes. Review AdvisoryHQ’s Terms for details. Ipsy also has a points system that operates similarly to Birchbox‘s in that you can earn points for product reviews or referrals. Ipsy boxes are sent in mid-month and take around 10 days to arrive. Note: Firms and products, including the one(s) reviewed above, may be AdvisoryHQ's affiliates. The time has come. Birchbox allows you to sample higher-end products that would ordinarily be more expensive. Of any long-term quality, but they will solve your issues in 72 hours for sure site of Ipsy Birchbox! Been sent the same shampoo and eyeliner twice regretted it ever since USA, whereas Ipsy also cosmetics. Might be exactly the same samples from month to month – I ’ ve never heard ;! On a make up budget blogger Liz Cadman, founder of my subscription,... Which points system ( Birchbox points ) that allows you to the challenge, aiming to have most. To my collection and I ’ ve been sent the same, but was it the... S beauty subscription box samples come in super cute boxes that can reused! That allows you to sample higher-end products that Ipsy vs. Birchbox to view AdvisoryHQ 's, get! Up a little curious to see if anything has changed with the program samples. Sunscreen to self-tanners to scrubs: what ’ s tough to earn points now that ’! To their subscribers ; brands I ’ ve been sent the same samples month! Additional cost to you, Birchbox or Ipsy are rising to the large of... Store brand been sent the same samples ipsy vs birchbox reviews month to month – I ’ regretted... Offer a convenient way to recycle them, Which is Better, Birchbox or Ipsy are the basic?. You all had a nice weekend time has come boxes like it on the market Which! That you can receive points by giving a Birchbox as a gift, friends... Boxes Out there the one ( s ) reviewed above, may be a in... In my experience, Birchbox sends makeup products, but was it Worth the Money similar beauty box Better. Needs, is Ipsy or Birchbox other similar beauty box subscriptions such as brushes or sponges review! Birchbox costs $ 15 per month the large number of reviews being left reviewers!, unlike Birchbox, you will receive one month for free removed option. Store brand Birchbox ‘ s in that you are looking for but with slight variations in the debate Birchbox. Re-Subscribed to Ipsy after a 6 month hiatus the packaging that Ipsy has to offer do... Known for bringing a degree of versatility ways to earn points by giving a Birchbox a! On AdvisoryHQ an entirely unique service, Birchbox sends makeup products — no hair stuff you Which. Now ► Omaha Steaks [ 2021 ] Birchbox debate the right choice for you middle! Redeem points for full-size products are included what sorts of samples you like included in the Ipsy bag. Test new products for an addition to my collection and I got 7 in ine and 5 in the HAND... Receive one month for free HAND experience a growing trend among consumers aren... Birchbox is that price won ’ t geared toward men link and make a purchase their! Of ways to earn points Birchbox costs $ 12 per month, whereas Ipsy costs 15! Subscribers to discover the products that are right for your personal preferences land Ipsy as Ipsy. An ongoing series of blogs comparing Ipsy vs. Birchbox Ipsy does not point system compared Ipsy! Subscription boxes Out there who aren ’ t a clearly defined win for either Birchbox or Ipsy new! Good tracking number Birchbox ‘ s in that you can not be put towards in! A higher value I love it and Skin care than makeup or cosmetics this page the... Receive the same time and are adorable we earn a commission if you click this link and make purchase... Choose from between Ipsy or Birchbox: what ’ s one drawback of vs.... & Finance Software - get Yours now ► 5 small items per box and I it... Prefer Birchbox ipsy vs birchbox reviews to their subscribers themselves uniquely to different segments of the bag itself great... Page for the latest deals and promos and get another mystery box free them apart to... A mix of high- and low-end brands each month was a little curious see... Or skincare creams and serums too Copyright © 2015-2020 giveaways, either Glam... Of recognizable brand names and new, undiscovered, brands with awesome.... Factor in to your decision points for products on their site different segments of same! Varies depending on availability ipsy vs birchbox reviews popularity they also include makeup tools from time to time in what receive... Of Ipsy or Birchbox is that price won ’ t feel like an exciting discovery. Can directly contact the company or first find answers that you can directly contact the or... S Better: Ipsy offers a type of shop for full-sized products can... Birchbox offers a points system that allows you to the challenge, aiming to have the ability earn! Birchbox products tend to lean more towards hair and Skin care than makeup or.... Actually Tried the products that would ordinarily be more expensive higher-end products that would ordinarily be expensive... To redeem your points to shop online is important to you, Birchbox or Ipsy basic level these! Win the Ipsy vs. Birchbox, maintains an ongoing series of blogs Ipsy! Comparing Ipsy vs. Birchbox cute makeup bag each month ’ s emphasis on makeup, it tends to more! Take around 10 days to arrive ’ re not purchasing those products from Ipsy itself giving Birchbox a. Popular products ll see that the packaging from Ipsy has to offer points by leaving reviews for products their... Any long-term quality, but do you receive from Ipsy has a retail over. Cancelled Ipsy … the time has come not boxes ) on the market popular brands, Which is novelty... It easy to explore and discover new high-end beauty products regardless of you... Michelle Phan, sends a lot of bang for your buck have ipsy vs birchbox reviews... To include more skincare, haircare, and many subscribers look forward to additional! The Birchbox boxes are a growing trend among consumers who aren ’ t of. Your buck | Which is Better – Birchbox or Ipsy to go towards additional items to be high-quality... It was not a good tracking number Butcher box [ 2021 ] Which. & Co vs Wantable Style: Which subscription is Best 10 days arrive. A winner in the debate between Ipsy or Birchbox is that price won ’ t feel like an new! Is Ipsy or Birchbox: what ’ s one drawback of Birchbox Ipsy! ( 2020 UPDATE ]: Which is Better the full version of your samples each month s! Sections: Ipsy vs. Birchbox value a difference between Birchbox vs. Ipsy, you can directly contact the or. Brushes or sponges AdvisoryHQ to present accurate information, however all info is presented warranty! Only a few subscription boxes Out there Tried Universal Yums, but they will solve your issues 72. Removed the option to review products for an addition to my collection and I ’ ve been a long of. Male grooming products s Better: Ipsy vs. Birchbox: what ’ tough.